Behr vs. Benjamin Moore: A Comprehensive Comparison from a Painting Pro

Bob Thomas

Introduction

Hello, dear readers! Bob Thomas here.

You know, back in my heyday as a professional painter and decorator, one of the most common questions I'd get asked was "Behr or Benjamin Moore?"

Well, today, we're going to dive deep into this topic, comparing these two top-tier paint brands head-to-head.

As always, I'll be sharing some of my personal experiences and pro tips to help you make the best choice for your next painting project.

Quick Summary

Choosing between Behr and Benjamin Moore can be tricky. Both brands offer high-quality paints with impressive durability. Behr stands out for its affordability and wide accessibility, while Benjamin Moore is known for its superior color range and consistency. Ultimately, your decision may hinge on factors such as your budget, color preferences, and the specific painting project at hand.

Behr Paint: Affordable and Accessible

When it comes to a good balance of quality and cost, Behr paints hold their own.

Found in most Home Depot stores, their accessibility is a massive plus, especially for those spontaneous weekend DIY projects.

Quality and Performance

From my experience, Behr Premium Plus, their top-tier line, provides excellent coverage and durability.

It's a paint and primer combo, ideal for both interior and exterior projects. It's a low VOC product, which is better for you and the environment.

Color Selection

Behr offers a broad color palette, though not as extensive as Benjamin Moore's.

However, their color matching system at Home Depot is reliable and can help you achieve the shade you're looking for.

Price Point

One of the major selling points of Behr paint is its affordability. It's a great option for those on a budget but still wanting a paint that performs well and lasts.

Pro Tip: For a smoother finish when using Behr paint, I recommend using a high-density foam roller. It minimizes brush marks and creates a professional-looking end result.

Benjamin Moore: Premium Quality and Color Variety

Benjamin Moore has long been a favorite among professionals and DIYers alike for its superior quality and extensive color selection.

Quality and Performance

In terms of quality, Benjamin Moore paints are hard to beat.

Their Regal Select line, in particular, stands out for its exceptional durability and coverage.

Plus, it's self-priming - a feature I've found incredibly convenient in my painting projects.

Color Selection

One of the standout features of Benjamin Moore is their extensive color palette. They offer over 3,500 colors! Plus, their color accuracy and consistency across different batches are second to none.

Price Point

Benjamin Moore is a premium paint brand, and its prices reflect that. It's more expensive than Behr, but many believe the quality justifies the cost.

Pro Tip: When using Benjamin Moore paint, make sure to pair it with a high-quality brush for the best results. This combination can truly bring out the paint's richness and smooth finish.

Personal Experiences

I remember a project from a few years back where I had to paint an entire Victorian-style home's exterior.

The client wanted a specific shade of blue, which we found in the Benjamin Moore catalogue. We used their Aura Exterior line, and I must say, the results were fantastic.

The paint was easy to work with, the coverage was great, and the color vibrancy was just as expected. To this day, that house stands as a testament to the longevity of Benjamin Moore paints.

On the other hand, when I painted my living room two years ago, I decided  to go with Behr's Premium Plus.

I wanted to spruce up the space without breaking the bank, and Behr seemed like the perfect fit. I chose a warm, neutral tone from their selection.

Applying the paint was a breeze, and the coverage was pretty impressive - I managed to finish the job with just two coats.

Now, two years later, the paint still looks fresh and has held up well against everyday wear and tear.

Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs)

Q. What type of paints does each brand offer?

  A: Both Behr and Benjamin Moore offer a wide variety of paint types. Behr offers interior and exterior paints, primers, stains, and specialty products like ceiling paint, chalk paint, and floor coatings.

Benjamin Moore also offers a comprehensive range of products, including interior and exterior paint, stain for wood, specialty coatings, and primers.

Q. Are Behr and Benjamin Moore environmentally friendly?

  A: Both Behr and Benjamin Moore have made efforts to produce eco-friendly paints. Behr's Premium Plus line is GreenGuard Gold certified, meaning it has low chemical emissions.

Benjamin Moore's Natura line is also GreenGuard Gold certified and is marketed as their greenest paint.

Q. Can I use these paints in a paint sprayer?

  A: Both Behr and Benjamin Moore paints can be used in a paint sprayer.

You might need to thin the paint slightly to avoid clogging the sprayer, depending on the paint's consistency and the type of sprayer you're using.

Q. How do Behr and Benjamin Moore paints perform in high-traffic areas?

  A: Benjamin Moore's Aura line and Behr's Marquee line are both formulated for excellent durability and are well-suited for high-traffic areas.

They resist mildew, stains, and scuffs, making them ideal for areas like hallways and playrooms.

Q. How well do these paints cover dark colors?

  A: The ability of paint to cover dark colors largely depends on the specific product line.

However, both Benjamin Moore's Regal and Behr's Marquee lines have been praised for their excellent coverage capabilities, often covering dark colors in one or two coats.

Q. How can I find the best color match between the two brands?

  A: Both Behr and Benjamin Moore offer color matching services. You can take a color sample to a retailer, and they can match it using their color technology systems.

Q. What are the warranties for Behr and Benjamin Moore paints?

  A: Both Behr and Benjamin Moore stand behind their products with limited warranties.

For the exact terms and conditions of their warranties, you should visit their official websites or speak with a retailer.

Q. How do these brands compare in terms of availability?

  A: Behr is widely available at home improvement stores like Home Depot.

Benjamin Moore is typically found at dedicated paint and decorating stores. 

However, both brands offer online shopping and delivery options.

Q. Do these brands offer color consultations?

  A: Benjamin Moore offers professional color consultations through its network of independent retailers.

Behr does not officially offer this service, but many Home Depot stores have knowledgeable staff who can provide guidance.

Q. How do the two brands compare for exterior paint?

  A: Both brands offer high-quality exterior paints.

Behr's Premium Plus Ultra Exterior Paint and Primer in One has excellent durability and fade resistance. 

Benjamin Moore's Aura Exterior has outstanding color retention and resists cracking, peeling, and fading.

Conclusion

Deciding between Behr and Benjamin Moore ultimately comes down to your project specifics and personal preferences.

If you're on a budget or need paint quickly and conveniently, Behr is a solid choice. It offers good quality paint that's easy to find and won't break the bank.

However, if you're looking for superior quality, an extensive color palette, and don't mind paying a bit more, Benjamin Moore is a fantastic option.

Its durability, color consistency, and premium finish make it a favorite among professionals.

In the end, both Behr and Benjamin Moore have their strengths, and either could be the right choice depending on your project's needs.

As a painting pro, I've had great experiences with both brands, and I'm confident you will too.

To wrap up, remember that no matter which paint brand you choose, good preparation is the key to a successful paint job.

Always ensure your surfaces are clean and primed before painting for the best results.

Suggested Products:  

Behr:

  1. Behr Marquee Interior Paint and Primer: This is Behr's most advanced interior paint and primer. It's known for its exceptional hide and superior durability. The One-Coat guarantee ensures that the most advanced colors can be achieved in fewer coats.
  2. Behr Premium Plus Ultra Exterior Paint and Primer in One: This exterior paint is excellent for various surfaces, including wood, vinyl, metal, and more. It's known for its excellent durability, fade resistance, and the ability to resist mildew, stains, and weathering.
  3. Behr DeckOver: This is a 100% acrylic formula that conceals cracks and splinters up to 1/4". It's great for bringing new life to old wood and concrete surfaces. It also creates a smooth, slip-resistant finish that's great for decks, patios, and sidewalks.

Benjamin Moore:

  1. Benjamin Moore Aura Interior Paint: Aura is known for its remarkable durability, exceptional coverage, and the ability to dry to a uniform, lustrous finish. It uses proprietary Color Lock technology, which enhances the color's richness and depth.
  2. Benjamin Moore Regal Select Exterior Paint: Regal Select offers excellent flow and leveling properties, which result in a smooth, uniform finish with outstanding durability. It's resistant to fading, cracking, peeling, and blistering, even in harsh weather conditions.
  3. Benjamin Moore Advance Interior Paint: Advance is a waterborne alkyd paint that offers the application and performance of traditional oil paint in a waterborne formula. It's ideal for interior doors, trim, cabinets, and furniture, offering outstanding flow and leveling and a smooth, hard finish.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}