Sherwin-Williams vs. Pratt & Lambert: Which Paint Reigns Supreme?

Bob Thomas

Hello there, fellow DIY enthusiasts and professional painters alike!

If you’re anything like me, you’ve likely stood in the paint aisle, pondering which brand of paint to trust with your upcoming project.

Today, we’re diving into a detailed comparison of two major players in the paint industry: Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert.

Buckle up, it’s time to add some color to our conversation!

Quick Summary

Debating between Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert for your next painting project? Here’s a quick rundown of the main differences: Sherwin-Williams offers excellent coverage and a wide range of colors at a higher price point. Pratt & Lambert, on the other hand, stands out for its durability, slightly lower price, and eco-friendly options. To make the best decision, consider your project’s specifics, your budget, and your personal preferences.



Sherwin-Williams is a well-respected name in the paint industry, known for its high-quality paint products and broad color selection.

While their paint is on the pricier side, many decorators and homeowners find the investment worthwhile given the excellent coverage and finish.

They are a very popular brand within the professional painters community.  

Pratt & Lambert

Pratt & Lambert, another long-standing brand, is recognized for its exceptional durability and quality.

While their color range may not be as expansive as Sherwin-Williams, their paint offers long-lasting results.

Notably, Pratt & Lambert carries an environmentally friendly line of products, making it a top choice for those aiming for a more sustainable project.

Coverage and Durability

Sherwin-Williams paint is renowned for its excellent coverage.

A little goes a long way, often requiring fewer coats than other brands.

This can save you both time and effort—something I appreciated when painting my living room last year. 

Pratt & Lambert paints, while offering good coverage, truly shine in their durability.

They’re formulated to withstand daily wear and tear and hold up well over time.

Remember that longevity is a key consideration, particularly in high-traffic areas.

Price and Availability

Sherwin-Williams paint tends to be on the higher end of the price spectrum.

However, they frequently run sales and promotions, making it more affordable.

Their stores are widespread, making it relatively easy to find their products.

Pratt & Lambert paints are typically a bit more affordable than Sherwin-Williams.

Their products are sold through various distributors, though they might not be as easily accessible depending on your location.

Color Options and Environmental Impact

Sherwin-Williams boasts an extensive color palette to cater to diverse tastes.

Whether you’re looking for a cool blue for your bedroom or a vibrant red for your dining room, you’ll likely find it here.

However, they don’t currently offer a specific line of eco-friendly paints.

On the flip side, Pratt & Lambert’s color range, while slightly more limited, is thoughtfully curated.

Most importantly, they offer an environmentally friendly paint line called “Accolade”.

This line boasts low VOC levels, which contributes to better indoor air quality—a win for both you and our planet.

Additional Considerations

Beyond the main points of coverage, durability, price, color options, and environmental impact, there are a few other factors worth considering when choosing between Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert.

Sheen and Finish Options

Both Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert offer a range of finishes, from flat and eggshell to semi-gloss and high gloss.

The type of sheen you select can dramatically impact the overall appearance of your painted surface.

For example, higher gloss paints are more reflective and can make a room seem brighter, while flat or matte finishes absorb light and can make colors appear deeper.

Ease of Application

Both brands offer products that are relatively easy to apply, but ease of application can vary based on the specific product line and type of paint.

Some paints are more forgiving and easy to apply evenly, while others might require more care to avoid visible brush strokes or roller marks.

Check reviews and ask for recommendations from store staff or professional painters.

Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs)

Q. Can I use Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert paints interchangeably?

  A: While you can certainly switch between Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert paints, keep in mind that they each have unique properties and may behave differently on different surfaces or under different conditions.

Always test a small area first if you’re switching paint brands mid-project.

Q. Are there other brands that compare closely to Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert?

  A: Yes, other high-quality paint brands that are often compared to Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert include Benjamin Moore and Behr.

However, each brand has its own unique features and formulations, so it’s crucial to do your research and choose the brand that best suits your specific needs.

Q. Do both Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert offer paint products for both indoor and outdoor use?

  A: Yes, both Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert offer a variety of products suitable for both indoor and outdoor use.

Be sure to choose the correct product for your project, taking into account factors such as weather resistance for outdoor paints and washability for indoor paints.

Q. I have a wooden furniture piece. Which brand would be more suitable for painting it?

  A: Both Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert produce paints that would work well on furniture.

The best choice depends on the type of finish you want, the color you’re interested in, and other factors specific to your project.

As always, prepare the surface properly and apply the paint according to the manufacturer’s instructions for the best result.

Q. How do I know if I need a primer before applying these paints?

  A: The need for a primer depends on the surface you’re painting and the paint you’re using.

In general, a primer is recommended when painting porous surfaces, when making a drastic color change, or when painting over a darker color with a lighter one.

Some Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert paints include primer in their formula, eliminating the need for a separate primer coat.


The choice between Sherwin-Williams and Pratt & Lambert will ultimately depend on your specific needs, budget, and color preferences.

If coverage and color options are your top priorities, Sherwin-Williams might be your best bet.

If durability and environmental impact are more important to you, consider Pratt & Lambert.

Suggested Products:


  1. Emerald Interior Acrylic Latex Paint: This is a premium line of paint that provides exceptional coverage, durability, and washability. It features innovative stain-blocking technology and is available in a wide variety of colors and finishes.
  2. Duration Exterior Acrylic Coating: Duration is a high-quality exterior paint known for its outstanding durability and long-lasting finish. It is formulated to withstand harsh weather conditions and is resistant to peeling and staining.
  3. ProClassic Interior Waterbased Acrylic-Alkyd: This is a high-quality interior paint ideal for doors, trim, and cabinets. It provides a smooth, durable finish that’s resistant to blocking, making it a favorite among professionals and DIYers alike.

Pratt & Lambert

  1. Accolade Interior Premium Paint & Primer: Accolade is a top-tier interior paint that provides excellent coverage and durability. It’s easy to apply, offers great color accuracy, and is formulated to resist common household stains.
  2. RedSeal Exterior Premium Paint: RedSeal is a durable exterior paint that provides excellent protection against the elements. It offers great adhesion, resistance to fading and cracking, and is available in a wide array of colors.
  3. Skylight Ceiling Paint: This specialized product is designed to provide a flawless, streak-free finish for ceilings. It has excellent coverage, dries quickly, and its ultra-flat finish helps hide imperfections.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}