Benjamin Moore vs PPG Pittsburgh Paints: A Painter’s Detailed Analysis

Bob Thomas

Introduction

Hey there, fellow DIY enthusiasts!

You must be planning a painting project if you're pondering between Benjamin Moore and PPG Pittsburgh Paints.

As a seasoned painter and decorator, I've had the opportunity to work with a myriad of paint brands.

Today, we're going to compare two of the heavyweights - Benjamin Moore and PPG Pittsburgh Paints - to help you pick the perfect paint for your project.

Quick Summary

In a hurry? Here's the gist: Benjamin Moore is renowned for its expansive color palette and exceptional durability, perfect for high-traffic areas. PPG Pittsburgh Paints, on the other hand, delivers excellent coverage and is a more budget-friendly option. For an in-depth comparison, keep on reading. Remember, the right choice largely depends on your specific project and budget.

Benjamin Moore: Color and Durability in Harmony

As a seasoned painter, I've found that Benjamin Moore offers an unparalleled variety of colors.

Whether you're going for a vibrant, energetic hue or a calming pastel shade, Benjamin Moore has got you covered.

When I painted my extra bedroom with their Aura Interior line last year, I was amazed by the paint's durability.

The finish has remained resilient, even in the face of my energetic son and his colorful toys.

I'd recommend Benjamin Moore's products for high-traffic areas and households with pets or children.

Pro Tip: If you're going with Benjamin Moore, consider their color fan deck - an excellent tool to visualize the colors before making a choice.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints: Superior Coverage on a Budget

PPG Pittsburgh Paints shines when it comes to coverage.

Its Manor Hall line, in particular, has been my go-to for clients seeking a transformative update on a budget.

A single coat often does the trick, saving time and reducing the quantity needed.

The cost-effectiveness of PPG Pittsburgh doesn't mean they compromise on quality.

The Manor Hall line, for example, offers excellent durability.

However, if you're looking for an extensive color palette like Benjamin Moore, you might find PPG Pittsburgh's selection a bit more limited.

Pro Tip: The PPG Voice of Color is a handy tool to explore their color offerings.

Comparison Table

Benjamin Moore
PPG Pittsburgh Paints

Color Variety

Extensive

Limited

Durability

High

Medium-High

Coverage

Good

Excellent

Price

Premium

Affordable

Best For

High-traffic areas, extensive color selection

Budget-friendly renovations, superior coverage


Personal Experiences

I've had the opportunity to work with both Benjamin Moore and PPG Pittsburgh Paints extensively.

Once, I was hired for a budget home renovation where the client wanted to completely transform their dark and dated interiors.

I suggested PPG Pittsburgh's Manor Hall line, and the results were impressive!

We managed to brighten up the space significantly with just a single coat.

On the other hand, while working on a Victorian house restoration, the client wanted a very specific pastel shade for their exterior.

Benjamin Moore's extensive color options came to our rescue.

The Aura Exterior line not only provided the desired hue but also stood the test of weather and time, maintaining its sheen and color even years later.

Frequently Asked Questions Sections (FAQs)

Q. Is Benjamin Moore paint more durable than PPG Pittsburgh Paints?

  A: While both brands provide high-quality paints, durability often depends on the specific product line and the conditions it will be exposed to.

Both Benjamin Moore and PPG Pittsburgh Paints have lines of paint known for their durability. Benjamin Moore's Regal Select line, for example, is praised for its exceptional durability.

Similarly, PPG's Timeless Exterior line is known for resisting cracking, peeling, and fading.

So, to answer this question, it's best to compare specific lines rather than the entire brand.

Q. Which brand has a wider color selection, Benjamin Moore or PPG Pittsburgh Paints?

  A: Both brands offer an extensive color palette, but Benjamin Moore is known for its particularly wide range of colors.

However, PPG Pittsburgh Paints also has a broad selection, and certain shades might only be available in one or the other.

Therefore, your choice might depend more on the particular shade you're looking for rather than the overall color range.

Q. Is PPG Pittsburgh Paints more eco-friendly than Benjamin Moore?

  A: Both brands have made strides towards environmentally friendly options.

PPG has a line of zero-VOC paints under its Pure Performance range.

Similarly, Benjamin Moore has its Natura line, which is zero-VOC and certified asthma and allergy-friendly. 

The eco-friendliness of a paint will largely depend on the specific product line from either brand.

Q. Which paint brand is more affordable, PPG Pittsburgh Paints or Benjamin Moore?

  A: PPG Pittsburgh Paints generally tend to be more affordable than Benjamin Moore.

However, the exact cost can vary depending on the specific product line and the retailer.

Remember, though, that paint quality often correlates with price, so a higher upfront cost might lead to better durability and fewer coats needed.

Q. Does Benjamin Moore or PPG Pittsburgh Paints offer better coverage?

  A: Coverage can vary widely depending on the specific paint line and color.

However, both brands have products known for excellent coverage. 

Benjamin Moore’s Aura line and PPG’s Manor Hall line, for instance, are highly regarded for their coverage.

Always check the specifications of the particular paint you're interested in to ensure it meets your coverage needs.

Q. Which brand offers better customer service, PPG Pittsburgh Paints or Benjamin Moore?

  A: Both brands generally receive good reviews for their customer service, though individual experiences can vary.

Both companies offer expert advice in-store and online to assist customers with their painting projects.

If customer service is a critical factor for you, it might be beneficial to visit local stores from each brand to compare the level of service firsthand.

Conclusion

Choosing between Benjamin Moore and PPG Pittsburgh Paints truly depends on your specific project needs.

If you're on the hunt for a specific color or need paint for high-traffic areas, Benjamin Moore is an excellent choice.

On the other hand, if you're looking for superior coverage on a budget, PPG Pittsburgh Paints will serve you well.

Suggested Products:

Benjamin Moore

  1. Benjamin Moore Aura: This is a premium line of paint known for exceptional coverage, durability, and color vibrancy. Aura uses Color Lock technology for richer colors and superior fade resistance. It's available in several finishes, including matte, satin, and semi-gloss.

  2. Benjamin Moore Regal Select: This paint-and-primer combination is highly regarded for its easy application and excellent durability. It's resistant to mildew even in humid conditions, making it a great choice for bathrooms and kitchens. Regal Select is available in various finishes and a wide array of colors.

  3. Benjamin Moore Natura: As one of Benjamin Moore's greenest paints, Natura is zero-VOC and zero-emissions, making it a healthier choice for your home. It has been certified asthma and allergy-friendly, and despite its eco-friendly formulation, it still offers great coverage and durability.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints

  1. PPG Timeless: This premium paint-and-primer-in-one offers excellent durability and resistance to weathering. It is especially popular for exterior applications. Timeless includes UV-protective components to resist fading and maintain the vibrancy of the color.

  2. PPG Diamond: This is a high-performing, budget-friendly paint. PPG Diamond provides excellent coverage, easy application, and long-lasting durability. It's also a paint-and-primer in one, saving you a step in your painting process.

  3. PPG Pure Performance: This line offers zero-VOC paints, providing a healthier choice for your home and the environment. Despite its eco-friendly formulation, Pure Performance doesn't skimp on performance, offering good coverage and durability.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}