Benjamin Moore vs. Pratt & Lambert: Which Is the Better Paint for Your Home Project

Bob Thomas

If you’re planning a home painting project, selecting the right paint can be quite daunting with so many brands out there.

As a seasoned painter and decorator, I’ve been there, done that!

Two of the most popular choices that people often find themselves torn between are Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert.

Well, don’t fret! This detailed comparison guide will take you through both brands to help you decide which one is best suited for your needs.

Quick Summary

When comparing Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert, both have their merits.

Benjamin Moore is renowned for its extensive color options and superior durability, while Pratt & Lambert excel in coverage and eco-friendliness.

Price points and availability may vary, so it’s crucial to consider these factors before making your final decision.

The Showdown

  1. Overview
  • Benjamin Moore: Established in 1883, Benjamin Moore is known for its commitment to producing high-quality paints that professionals swear by. From my experience, its paints deliver outstanding performance, from adhesion to coverage.
  • Pratt & Lambert: Founded in 1849, Pratt & Lambert has a long-standing reputation for premium quality. I’ve found their paints to be reliable and consistently provide a smooth, high-quality finish.
  1. Coverage and Durability
  • Benjamin Moore: With a reputation for high-quality paints, Benjamin Moore offers excellent coverage.

For instance, the Benjamin Moore Regal Select covers flawlessly in just two coats.

It also scores high in durability – I painted my living room with this a few years back, and it still looks fresh!

  • Pratt & Lambert: Known for its superior hide capability, Pratt & Lambert paints often cover well even with just a single coat.

Their Accolade line, for example, is renowned for its excellent coverage and long-lasting durability.

  1. Price
  • Benjamin Moore: While it offers a wide range of products catering to different budgets, Benjamin Moore is generally considered a premium brand with a higher price tag.
  • Pratt & Lambert: This brand also falls in the premium category. However, its pricing is generally lower than Benjamin Moore, offering a cost-effective option without compromising on quality.
  1. Availability
  • Benjamin Moore: This brand has a vast network of independently owned paint and hardware stores across the country.
  • Pratt & Lambert: While its products are available nationwide, the network is less extensive than Benjamin Moore’s. This might limit your options when it comes to in-store purchases.
  1. Color Options
  • Benjamin Moore: With over 3,500 colors to choose from, Benjamin Moore has one of the widest selections I’ve seen. Their color palette is always up-to-date with the latest trends too.
  • Pratt & Lambert: While the color options aren’t as extensive as Benjamin Moore’s, Pratt & Lambert still offers a rich palette of around 1,000 hues, all of which

Pro Tip: Take advantage of the free color swatches available at paint stores. They allow you to see how a specific color looks in your space under different lighting conditions.

Environmental Impact

The final factor to consider when comparing Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert is their environmental impact.

Benjamin Moore is committed to environmental responsibility.

Many of their products, including their popular Natura and Aura lines, carry the Green Promise designation, meaning they are low-VOC (Volatile Organic Compounds) or zero-VOC paints.

Additionally, Benjamin Moore has adopted sustainable business practices, like reducing waste and energy usage in their manufacturing processes.

Pratt & Lambert, on the other hand, also places a strong emphasis on producing eco-friendly products.

They offer low-VOC and zero-VOC paints as well, including the RedSeal, Accolade, and Aquanamel lines.

Moreover, Pratt & Lambert also strives to minimize their environmental footprint through responsible manufacturing practices.

Personal Experiences

I remember when I was painting a client’s living room a few years back.

They were particularly sensitive to strong odors and were worried about the VOC content in paints. I recommended Benjamin Moore’s Natura line, a zero-VOC, virtually odorless paint.

The client was delighted with the result – the paint provided excellent coverage, and they didn’t have to deal with unpleasant smells during or after the painting process.

Conversely, for a different project where the client was on a tighter budget, I opted for Pratt & Lambert’s RedSeal line.

It was an economical choice that didn’t compromise on quality.

The paint was low-VOC, provided good coverage, and proved to be durable in the long run.

Frequently Asked Questions Sections (FAQs)

Q. What types of paint finishes do Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert offer?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert offer a range of finishes from flat to high gloss.

These include flat, matte, eggshell, satin, semi-gloss, and high gloss.

The right finish for you depends on the room you’re painting, the atmosphere you want to create, and how much durability you need.

Q. Are there specialty paints available from these brands?

  A: Yes, both brands offer specialty paints. Benjamin Moore, for example, has a line of chalkboard paint, metallic paint, and studio finishes for special effects.

Pratt & Lambert offers unique products like a ceiling paint that goes on pink and dries white to ensure you don’t miss a spot, and a line of specialty coatings for different materials and purposes.

Q. Do these brands offer color matching services?

  A: Yes, both Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert offer color matching services.

You can bring in a sample of a color you love, and they can match it as closely as possible.

Q. What are their policies on returns or exchanges if I’m not satisfied with the color?

  A: The policies on returns or exchanges may vary depending on the store you purchase from, so it’s a good idea to check the policy before buying.

Some stores may not accept returns on custom-mixed paint.

Always do a patch test of the color at home before purchasing large quantities.

Q. How do these brands perform in terms of drying time and re-coating?

  A: Generally, both brands perform well in terms of drying time and re-coating.

However, drying time can be affected by factors like temperature, humidity, and the type of paint you’re using.

Always follow the instructions on the paint can for best results.

Q. How do these paint brands hold up over time?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert are known for their durability.

The longevity of the paint will also depend on factors like the environment it’s in (for example, a bathroom might have more humidity), the preparation of the surface before painting, and whether the paint is applied correctly.

Q. What kind of primers do these brands offer?

  A: Both brands offer a range of primers designed to work with their paints.

They have primers for different surfaces (wood, drywall, metal, etc.) and conditions (stain-blocking, high-humidity areas, etc.).

It’s essential to use a primer to get the best performance out of your paint.

Q. Can I order paints from these brands online?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert paints could be ordered online in some areas, but this may vary depending on your location and the specific retailer.

It’s always best to check the brands’ official websites or call your local paint store for the most accurate information.

Q. How can I find the closest store selling these brands?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Pratt & Lambert have store locators on their websites where you can input your location and find the nearest retailer.

Q. How can I properly dispose of leftover paint from these brands?

  A: You should never pour paint down the drain or throw it in the regular trash.

Both brands recommend checking with your local waste disposal facility to find out how to properly dispose of or recycle leftover paint.


When it comes to Benjamin Moore vs. Pratt & Lambert, the choice largely depends on your individual needs and preferences.

Benjamin Moore excels in terms of color variety and coverage but comes with a higher price tag.

On the other hand, Pratt & Lambert offers great value for money with their high-quality, durable paints.

Both companies demonstrate a strong commitment to producing eco-friendly products and minimizing their environmental impact.

Therefore, whichever brand you choose, you can be sure that you’re making an environmentally responsible choice.

Remember, the key to a successful painting project lies not just in choosing the right paint but also in proper preparation and application.

Always ensure your surfaces are clean, primed, and ready to be painted, and don’t rush the painting process.

Good luck with your next painting project!

Suggested Products:

Benjamin Moore

  1. Regal Select: This is a versatile paint that can be used for various indoor applications. It has excellent hide and coverage characteristics, is highly durable, and comes in multiple finishes.
  2. Aura Interior Paint: Known for its remarkable color depth and richness, this paint is also very durable and has built-in primer properties, making it a great choice for walls that need a bit of extra attention.
  3. Advance Interior Paint: A high-end paint for cabinets, doors, and trim. It offers a furniture-like finish, has excellent leveling properties, and is available in low luster, satin, semi-gloss, and high-gloss finishes.

Pratt & Lambert

  1. Accolade Interior Paint: An acrylic latex paint that is known for its excellent flow and leveling properties, great adhesion, and superior durability. It can be used on a wide variety of surfaces and comes in a full spectrum of colors and finishes.
  2. RedSeal Porch & Floor Enamel: This is a durable, weather-resistant paint that is ideal for use on concrete, wood, or metal surfaces both indoors and out. It’s resistant to abrasion and fading and provides a mildew-resistant coating.
  3. Aquatex House & Trim Paint: An exterior paint known for its great coverage, easy application, and weather resistance. It’s ideal for painting siding, trim, and doors, and is formulated to resist fading and mildew growth.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}