Benjamin Moore vs. Valspar – Which Paint Should You Choose?

Bob Thomas

Hello, fellow DIY enthusiasts and professional decorators alike!

I’m Bob Thomas, your go-to source for all things painting and decorating. 

Today, I’m going to draw on my professional expertise and personal experiences to help you choose between two of the most popular paint brands out there: Benjamin Moore and Valspar.

Quick Summary

If you’re in a rush, here’s a brief rundown: Benjamin Moore is often favored for its superior quality and color range but can be a bit pricey. On the other hand, Valspar offers good quality at a more affordable price point, with excellent coverage and a wide variety of colors. The choice depends on your specific project needs and budget.

Benjamin Moore vs. Valspar: A Closer Look

As a seasoned painter and decorator, I’ve had the chance to work with many paint brands.

Two that stand out are Benjamin Moore and Valspar. Here’s how they stack up against each other.

Quality and Performance

Benjamin Moore: Known for its top-notch quality, Benjamin Moore paint tends to go on smoother, cover better, and last longer. 

It’s less prone to dripping and typically requires fewer coats.

Valspar: Valspar is no slouch either. It might require an extra coat or two for full coverage, but it generally applies well and lasts a decent amount of time.

Range of Colors

Benjamin Moore: With more than 3,500 colors available, Benjamin Moore offers a broad spectrum to choose from.

Their color accuracy is also commendable, ensuring you get the exact shade you’re after.

Valspar: Valspar competes well in this category, offering a diverse color palette.

However, some users have reported slight variations between the color swatch and the dried paint.


Benjamin Moore: Generally, Benjamin Moore paints are more expensive. You’re paying for the higher quality, and for many, the results are worth the extra cost.

Valspar: A more budget-friendly option, Valspar provides good quality paint at a lower price point.

It’s a go-to for those who need to paint large areas or are working on a tight budget.

Pro Tip: Always test a small amount of paint on your surface before committing to the entire project. This will give you a real-life view of the color and coverage you can expect.

Personal Experiences 

Many years ago, I took on the project of repainting my spare room.

I opted for Benjamin Moore’s Regal Select in ‘Pale Oak.’ Despite its slightly higher price tag, the quality of the paint was noticeable immediately. 

It went on smoothly and the color was exactly as I expected. It took just two coats to get complete coverage.

But that doesn’t mean I’ve never had success with Valspar.

I remember using Valspar’s Signature paint in ‘Seashell Gray’ for a friend’s bedroom makeover.

The price was unbeatable and, although it required an extra coat, the end result was impressive.

Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs) 

Q. Can I find eco-friendly options in both Benjamin Moore and Valspar paints?

  A: Absolutely. Both Benjamin Moore and Valspar have eco-friendly, low VOC (Volatile Organic Compounds) options.

Benjamin Moore’s “Natura” and Valspar’s “Simpy Perfect” lines are zero-VOC and have been independently certified as asthma and allergy friendly.

Q. How do Benjamin Moore and Valspar compare in terms of sheen options?

  A: Both brands offer a variety of sheens, from flat/matte to high-gloss.

These options allow you to customize the look and feel of your paint job to meet the specific requirements of your project.

Q. Which of the two brands offers better resistance to wear and tear?

  A: Generally, Benjamin Moore paints are considered more durable and resistant to wear and tear due to their superior quality formulation.

However, certain lines of Valspar, like the “Duramax” and “Signature,” also offer good resistance to everyday wear.

Q. How do these brands perform in different climates?

  A: Both brands have paints suitable for various climates.

Valspar’s “WeatherX” technology offers excellent weather-resistance, making it a good choice for harsh climates.

Benjamin Moore’s “Aura” line offers exceptional durability and color retention, even in extreme weather conditions.

Q. What are the unique features of each brand that set them apart?

  A: Benjamin Moore’s proprietary Gennex colorant technology ensures superb color accuracy and durability, while Valspar’s ScuffShield Technology promises excellent scuff resistance, especially important in high-traffic areas.

Q. How easy is it to clean painted surfaces?

  A: Paints from both Benjamin Moore and Valspar are typically easy to clean.

However, this can depend on the specific product line and sheen. High-gloss and semi-gloss paints are generally easier to clean than flat or eggshell sheens.

Q. Can I use these paints for both interiors and exteriors?

  A: Yes, both brands offer paints suitable for interior and exterior projects.

Be sure to choose the appropriate product for your specific needs – exterior paints are formulated to withstand weather, while interior paints are typically more resistant to scuffs and stains.


In conclusion, both Benjamin Moore and Valspar have their merits.

If you’re after top-of-the-line quality and don’t mind splashing out a bit more, Benjamin Moore might be your best bet.

However, if you’re working within a budget and still want good quality paint, Valspar should definitely be on your radar.

Suggested Products:  

Benjamin Moore

  1. Benjamin Moore Regal Select: An all-around excellent paint, Regal Select offers superior durability and coverage, easy application, and excellent color retention. It’s also self-priming for most surfaces.
  2. Benjamin Moore Aura: The Aura line is known for its extreme hide and coverage properties. It has a rich, full color that resists color fading, making it ideal for both interior and exterior use.
  3. Benjamin Moore Natura: This is Benjamin Moore’s greenest paint. It’s a zero-VOC paint, and it’s certified asthma- and allergy-friendly. Despite its eco-friendly features, it still offers the excellent coverage and durability Benjamin Moore is known for.


  1. Valspar Signature: This paint and primer in one provides great coverage, high durability, and a smooth finish. It’s also resistant to mildew and harsh weather, making it a good choice for both interior and exterior use.
  2. Valspar Duramax: The Duramax line is known for its excellent durability and weather resistance, making it an ideal exterior paint. It’s also a paint and primer in one and offers high hiding for darker colors.
  3. Valspar Reserve: This is Valspar’s highest-quality paint. It’s a paint and primer in one and offers excellent coverage, even on dark colors. It’s highly durable and stain-resistant, making it a great choice for high-traffic areas.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}