Can You Mix Semi-Gloss and Flat Paint Together? A Painter’s Guide

Bob Thomas
It's a yes, but there's a catch: they must both be oil-based or water-based. Intrigued? Dive deeper below!

As a seasoned painter and decorator, I've often been asked, "Bob, can you mix semi-gloss and flat paint together?"

It's a great question, and the answer might surprise you.

In this article, we'll delve into the world of paint finishes and explore whether you can mix semi-gloss and flat paint to achieve your desired look.

Quick Summary

Yes, you can mix semi-gloss and flat paint together, as long as they are both either oil-based or water-based: The resulting 1) finish will be a balance between the two, giving you a customized sheen that falls somewhere between 2) semi-gloss and flat. However, it's 3) crucial to test your mixture before applying it to a large area.

Understanding Paint Finishes

Before we dive into mixing paints, let's understand the difference between semi-gloss and flat paint.

Flat paint, also known as matte paint, has the least amount of shine.

It's great for hiding imperfections but isn't as durable or easy to clean as glossier finishes. 

On the other hand, semi-gloss paint has a subtle shine and is more durable and easier to clean, making it suitable for areas like kitchens and bathrooms.

The Possibility of Mixing Semi-Gloss and Flat Paint

You can mix semi-gloss and flat paint as long as they are the same medium - either both oil-based or both water-based.

The resulting finish will be a mid-sheen, often similar to an eggshell or satin finish.

How to Mix Semi-Gloss and Flat Paint

Mixing these two types of paint is relatively straightforward.

Start by pouring equal amounts of semi-gloss and flat paint into a paint bucket, then stir thoroughly until they're fully combined.

It's important to test your mixture on a small, inconspicuous area first to ensure you're happy with the resulting sheen.

If you want a shinier finish, add more semi-gloss paint; if you prefer a less shiny finish, add more flat paint.

Important:  Always mix your paints in a well-ventilated area and use a clean, dry stir stick to ensure a smooth, even blend.

The Results of Mixing Semi-Gloss and Flat Paint

When you mix semi-gloss and flat paint, you'll end up with a finish that has a sheen level somewhere between the two.

This can be a great way to customize your paint job, especially if you're looking for a specific level of glossiness that isn't available in pre-mixed paint cans.

Safety, Risks, and Considerations

While mixing semi-gloss and flat paint can be a great way to achieve a custom finish, there are a few safety considerations and potential risks to keep in mind.

Safety Precautions
  1. Ventilation: Always mix and apply paint in a well-ventilated area to avoid inhaling potentially harmful fumes. If you're working in an enclosed space, consider using a fan or opening windows to improve air circulation.
  2. Protective Gear: Wear protective clothing, including gloves and safety glasses, to protect your skin and eyes from splashes. If you're sensitive to paint fumes, consider wearing a mask or respirator.
  3. Proper Disposal: Dispose of any leftover paint and cleaning materials responsibly. Many local waste facilities offer paint recycling or disposal services.
Potential Risks
  1. Inconsistent Finish: If the paints aren't mixed thoroughly, you may end up with an inconsistent finish. To avoid this, make sure to stir your paint mixture well before application.
  2. Color Variation: If the semi-gloss and flat paint aren't the exact same color, mixing them could result in a slightly different hue. Always test your mixture on a small, inconspicuous area before applying it to a larger surface.
  3. Sheen Level: The sheen level of your mixed paint will be somewhere between semi-gloss and flat. If you're looking for a specific level of glossiness, you may need to adjust the ratio of semi-gloss to flat paint.
Considerations
  1. Type of Paint: Only mix paints of the same type. That means if one is oil-based, the other should be too. The same goes for water-based paints. Mixing oil and water-based paints can result in a clumpy, unusable mess.
  2. Test First: Always test your paint mixture on a small, hidden area first to ensure you're happy with the color and sheen.
  3. Storing Mixed Paint: If you have leftover mixed paint, store it in a tightly sealed container in a cool, dry place. Be sure to label the container with the date and a description of the paint mixture for future reference.

By following these safety precautions and being aware of the potential risks and considerations, you can safely and successfully mix semi-gloss and flat paint to achieve your desired finish.

Troubleshooting

While mixing semi-gloss and flat paint is generally a straightforward process, you might encounter a few issues along the way.

Here are some common problems and how to solve them:

  1. Problem: The Paints Aren't Mixing

Solution: This issue typically arises when you're trying to mix oil-based paint with water-based paint.

These two types of paint are incompatible due to their different bases.

Always ensure that the paints you're mixing are of the same type - either both oil-based or both water-based. 

If you've accidentally mixed different types, it's best to start over with new paint.

  1. Problem: The Mixed Paint Looks Streaky or Inconsistent

Solution: This could be due to insufficient mixing. Make sure to stir your paint mixture thoroughly until the two types of paint are completely blended.

Using a paint stirrer or a drill with a paint-mixing attachment can help ensure a consistent mix.

If the problem persists, it may be due to a significant difference in the quality or age of the two paints.

  1. Problem: The Sheen Level Isn't What I Expected

Solution: The sheen level of your mixed paint will be somewhere between that of semi-gloss and flat paint. If the sheen isn't what you expected, adjust the ratio of semi-gloss to flat paint.

Adding more semi-gloss paint will increase the sheen, while adding more flat paint will decrease it.

Remember to test your adjusted mixture on a small, inconspicuous area before applying it to a larger surface.

  1. Problem: The Mixed Paint is Clumpy or Has Separated After Storage

Solution: Paint can separate or become clumpy over time, especially if it's not stored properly.

If you have leftover mixed paint, make sure to store it in a tightly sealed container in a cool, dry place.

Before using stored paint, stir it thoroughly to recombine.

If the paint remains clumpy or separated despite stirring, it's best to discard it and start with fresh paint.

By being aware of these common issues and knowing how to troubleshoot them, you can ensure a successful and satisfying paint mixing experience.

Personal Experiences

I remember a project where I had leftover semi-gloss and flat paint in the same color.

Instead of letting the paint go to waste, I decided to mix them. The result was a unique custom finish that perfectly matched the room's aesthetic.

It was a win-win situation - I got to use up my leftover paint, and the room got a fresh, customized look!

Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs)

Q. Can I mix semi-gloss and flat paint of different colors?

  A: Yes, you can mix semi-gloss and flat paint of different colors. However, keep in mind that the resulting color will be a blend of the two original colors.

If you're aiming for a specific color, it's best to start with paints that are already close to your desired hue.

Q. Can I use mixed paint for any painting project?

  A: Mixed paint can be used for a variety of painting projects, but the resulting sheen level might not be suitable for all surfaces.

For instance, a mixture of semi-gloss and flat paint might not be shiny enough for areas that need to be easily cleaned, like kitchens or bathrooms, but could be perfect for living areas or bedrooms.

Q. How long can I store mixed paint?

  A: If stored properly, mixed paint can last for up to 2-5 years.

To maximize its shelf life, store the paint in a tightly sealed container in a cool, dry place. 

Be sure to label the container with the date and a description of the paint mixture for future reference.

Q. Can I mix semi-gloss and flat paint with different finishes, like metallic or chalky finish?

  A: While it's technically possible to mix paints with different finishes, the result might not be what you expect.

The unique properties of specialty finishes like metallic or chalky finish might not blend well with standard semi-gloss or flat paint.

It's best to test a small amount first to see if you're happy with the result.

Q. Can I mix semi-gloss and flat paint to touch up an existing paint job?

  A: If you're trying to match the sheen level of an existing paint job, mixing semi-gloss and flat paint might help.

However, keep in mind that factors like the age and wear of the existing paint can affect how well the touch-up blends in.

It's always a good idea to test the mixed paint on a hidden area first.

Conclusion

So, can you mix semi-gloss and flat paint together? Absolutely!

With a bit of careful mixing and testing, you can create a custom paint finish that perfectly suits your needs.

Just remember to ensure both paints are either oil-based or water-based, and always test your mixture before applying it to a large area. 

Suggested Products:

  1. High-Quality Semi-Gloss PaintA reliable semi-gloss paint is essential for achieving a good mix. One such product is the "Behr Premium Plus Semi-Gloss Enamel". It's known for its durability and easy application, making it a great choice for mixing with flat paint.
  2. Durable Flat Paint: A good flat paint, such as "Benjamin Moore's Ben Interior Flat Paint", can provide excellent coverage and a beautiful matte finish. When mixed with semi-gloss paint, it can help achieve the desired sheen level.
  3. Paint Mixing Bucket: A sturdy paint mixing bucket, like the "Encore Plastics Mix 'N Measure Container", is crucial for mixing paints. It has measurement markings on the side, which can help ensure you're mixing the right amounts of semi-gloss and flat paint.
  4. Paint Stirrer: A durable paint stirrer, such as the "Red Devil 4040 Heavy Duty Paint and Mud Mixer", can ensure a thorough mix of your semi-gloss and flat paint. This particular mixer can be attached to a drill for easy and efficient stirring.
  5. Safety Gear: Safety is paramount when handling paint. A set like the "3M Safety Kit", which includes gloves, safety glasses, and a respirator, can provide protection from potential paint splashes and fumes.

Remember, these are just suggestions. Always choose products that best suit your specific needs and preferences.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}