Can You Put Polyurethane Over Polycrylic? A Comprehensive Guide for DIY Enthusiasts

Bob Thomas

Introduction

As a qualified painter and decorator, I often receive questions about various finishes for wood projects.

One question that pops up frequently is whether it's possible to apply polyurethane over polycrylic.

To give you a clear and definitive answer, I have put together this comprehensive guide based on my experiences, so you can make an informed decision for your next woodworking project.

Quick Summary

  • Polyurethane and polycrylic are two popular finishes for wood, but they have different properties and uses.
  • It is not recommended to apply polyurethane over polycrylic due to potential adhesion issues and other problems.
  • For best results, stick to using one type of finish for your project, either polyurethane or polycrylic.

Understanding Polyurethane and Polycrylic

Before diving into the main question, it's important to understand the differences between polyurethane and polycrylic finishes.

Polyurethane:

  • A versatile and durable finish.
  • Available in oil-based and water-based versions.
  • Provides a warm, amber hue to the wood.
  • Suitable for high-traffic areas and outdoor projects.

Polycrylic:

  • A water-based finish.
  • Dries clear and doesn't yellow over time.
  • Less durable than polyurethane, making it ideal for low-traffic areas and indoor projects.
  • Faster drying time compared to polyurethane.

Why You Shouldn't Put Polyurethane Over Polycrylic

Adhesion Issues: Applying polyurethane over polycrylic can lead to adhesion problems. Polyurethane may not bond well with the polycrylic surface, causing the finish to peel or flake over time.

Uneven Finish: Mixing different finishes can result in an uneven appearance, which may not be the look you're aiming for.

Increased Drying Time: Applying polyurethane over polycrylic can prolong the drying time, making your project take longer to complete.

Incompatibility: Oil-based polyurethane and water-based polycrylic may not be compatible, leading to issues like bubbling or cloudiness in the finish.

Alternatives to Applying Polyurethane Over Polycrylic

If you're looking for a durable finish, consider these alternatives instead of applying polyurethane over polycrylic:

Stick to One Finish: Choose either polyurethane or polycrylic for your entire project, based on the specific needs and requirements of your woodworking project.

Sand and Refinish: If you've already applied polycrylic and want a more durable finish, you can sand down the polycrylic layer and apply polyurethane instead. Just be prepared for the extra work involved.

Use a Different Finish: There are other finishing options available, such as varnishes and lacquers, that may better suit your project's needs.

Some Sources Say You Can Do It?

While there are some sources that claim you can apply polyurethane over polycrylic, it's important to proceed with caution and be aware of the potential risks involved.

If you decide to try this approach, consider the following steps to minimize issues:

Testing Compatibility and Adhesion

To ensure the best results, test the compatibility and adhesion of polyurethane over polycrylic on a small, inconspicuous area before proceeding with the entire project.

  1. Prepare the Surface: Lightly sand the polycrylic-coated surface with a fine-grit sandpaper (320-grit or higher) to create a slightly rough texture for better adhesion.
  2. Clean the Surface: Remove any dust or debris from the surface using a tack cloth or a soft, lint-free cloth dampened with mineral spirits.
  3. Test a Small Area: Apply a thin layer of polyurethane to a small, inconspicuous area, and allow it to dry according to the manufacturer's instructions. After it has dried, check for adhesion issues, bubbling, or cloudiness. If the test area shows satisfactory results, proceed with the entire project.

Applying Polyurethane Over Polycrylic

If your test area results are positive, follow these steps to apply polyurethane over polycrylic:

  1. Lightly Sand the Surface: As mentioned earlier, lightly sand the polycrylic-coated surface with a fine-grit sandpaper to promote adhesion.
  2. Clean the Surface: Remove any sanding dust or debris from the surface using a tack cloth or a soft, lint-free cloth dampened with mineral spirits.
  3. Apply Thin Coats: Apply thin, even coats of polyurethane using a high-quality brush or foam applicator. Allow each coat to dry according to the manufacturer's instructions before applying additional coats.
  4. Sand Between Coats: Lightly sand between each coat of polyurethane with a fine-grit sandpaper (320-grit or higher) to ensure a smooth finish. Clean the surface again using a tack cloth or a lint-free cloth dampened with mineral spirits to remove any sanding residue.
  5. Final Coat: Apply the final coat of polyurethane, and let it dry according to the manufacturer's instructions. Once it's dry, your project should have a durable, protective finish.

Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs)

Q. Can I apply oil-based polyurethane over water-based polycrylic?

  A: Mixing oil-based and water-based finishes is generally not recommended due to potential compatibility issues.

However, if you decide to try, test a small inconspicuous area for adhesion and compatibility before proceeding with the entire project.

Q. How many coats of polyurethane should I apply over polycrylic?

  A: The number of coats depends on the desired level of protection and the finish's appearance.

Generally, 2-3 coats of polyurethane are recommended for most projects.

Be sure to sand lightly and clean the surface between coats for a smooth finish.

Q. Can I apply polycrylic over polyurethane?

  A: Similar to applying polyurethane over polycrylic, applying polycrylic over polyurethane may also result in adhesion and compatibility issues.

Test a small inconspicuous area before applying polycrylic over polyurethane.

Q. How long should I wait between applying polycrylic and polyurethane?

  A: Ensure that the polycrylic layer is fully cured before applying polyurethane.

The curing time varies depending on the product, but it's generally safe to wait at least 24 hours.

Check the manufacturer's instructions for specific curing times.

Q. Can I apply a clear coat over polycrylic for added protection?

  A: If you're looking for added protection without using polyurethane, consider a clear coat specifically designed to work with water-based finishes.

These clear coats are usually compatible with polycrylic and provide additional durability and protection.

Q. Can I use a spray polyurethane over polycrylic?

  A: Spray polyurethane can be used over polycrylic, but compatibility and adhesion issues may still arise.

Always test a small inconspicuous area before applying spray polyurethane over polycrylic.

Q. How do I fix adhesion issues if I've already applied polyurethane over polycrylic?

  A: If you're experiencing adhesion issues, you may need to sand the surface to remove the problematic layers of finish.

Once the surface is smooth, clean it thoroughly and reapply a compatible finish.

Conclusion

While it may be tempting to apply polyurethane over polycrylic for added protection, it's not recommended due to potential adhesion issues and other problems that may arise.

It's best to choose one finish that suits your project's needs and stick with it.

By following this advice, you'll be well on your way to achieving a beautiful and durable finish for your woodworking projects. 

Suggested Products:

  1. Minwax Polycrylic Protective Finish: A popular choice among DIY enthusiasts, this water-based, low-odor clear finish offers protection and durability for interior wood surfaces. It dries quickly, resists yellowing, and is available in various sheens.
  2. Varathane Water-Based Polyurethane: This water-based polyurethane is known for its clarity and durability. It is ideal for interior wood projects and provides a scratch-resistant finish with fast drying times.
  3. General Finishes High-Performance Water-Based Topcoat: This topcoat is designed to provide a durable finish with a beautiful sheen. It's an excellent choice for high-use surfaces and is compatible with various wood stains and finishes.
  4. Rust-Oleum Ultimate Polyurethane: Available in water-based and oil-based versions, this polyurethane is a versatile option for wood projects. It offers a durable finish that resists scratches and stains, making it suitable for high-traffic areas.
  5. Minwax Fast-Drying Polyurethane: As the name suggests, this oil-based polyurethane dries quickly and provides a long-lasting protective finish. It's suitable for various interior wood surfaces, including furniture, doors, and floors.
  6. Zar Ultra Max Waterborne Oil-Modified Polyurethane: This unique formula combines the advantages of oil-based and water-based polyurethanes. It offers a tough, abrasion-resistant finish while maintaining the low odor and easy cleanup of water-based products.
  7. Deft Interior Water-Based Clear Wood Finish: This water-based finish is known for its fast-drying properties and durable finish. It's ideal for interior wood surfaces, such as furniture, cabinets, and doors.
  8. Watco Lacquer Clear Wood Finish: This lacquer provides a crystal-clear, high-gloss finish that dries quickly and offers excellent protection for interior wood surfaces. It's an alternative to polyurethane and polycrylic finishes.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}