Olympic Vs. Benjamin Moore: Which Paint Should You Choose?

Bob Thomas

Hello there, I’m Bob Thomas, a seasoned painter, and decorator.

I’m excited to share my wealth of experience with you in making an informed choice between two well-known paint brands: Benjamin Moore and Olympic. Let’s dive right in!

Quick Summary

Deciding between Benjamin Moore and Olympic paints? Here are the key points: 1) Benjamin Moore offers a vast color palette, exceptional quality, and excellent coverage but can be pricey. 2) Olympic provides good quality paints at a more budget-friendly price, with fewer color options. 3) Your choice will depend on your budget, color preference, and desired paint quality.

Benjamin Moore Overview

Benjamin Moore, a top-tier paint brand, is well-regarded for its expansive color palette, boasting over 3500 hues to satisfy every imaginable color preference.

Known for its exceptional quality, Benjamin Moore’s paint has remarkable coverage, often requiring fewer coats than many other brands.

The result? You save time and effort during your painting project.

However, this quality comes with a heftier price tag compared to other brands like Olympic.

When I was actively painting and decorating, I’d often recommend Benjamin Moore for clients looking for unique colors and top-notch quality, and who didn’t mind a higher price.

Pro Tip: If you’re using a rich or dark Benjamin Moore color, consider their specific primer for the best results. It enhances the vibrancy and depth of the topcoat color.

Olympic Overview

Olympic, on the other hand, offers a more budget-friendly alternative without compromising too much on quality.

While its color options aren’t as extensive as Benjamin Moore, Olympic still provides a decent array of colors suitable for most homeowners.

From my personal experience, Olympic paint covers well and is relatively durable, which is excellent for DIY-ers and homeowners on a budget.

However, you may require an extra coat or two compared to Benjamin Moore to achieve the desired coverage, especially with darker colors.

Comparing Coverage and Durability

When it comes to coverage, Benjamin Moore often outperforms Olympic, needing fewer coats to achieve excellent opacity.

For durability, both brands offer long-lasting paint options, but Benjamin Moore’s premium lines may edge out Olympic in terms of overall longevity.

Pro Tip: Regardless of the paint brand you choose, always prepare your surfaces properly. Clean, repair any defects, and prime as needed for the best possible finish.

Price Point Comparison

In any project, the budget is always a key factor. When comparing the price points of Benjamin Moore and Olympic paints, we can see some differences that may influence your decision.

Benjamin Moore

Benjamin Moore is widely recognized for its superior quality, but this comes at a higher price point.

Their paints typically range from $50 to $70 per gallon. Keep in mind, the cost can vary depending on the specific product line and where you’re purchasing from.

However, given its durability and the beautiful finish it offers, many users find the price justified.

Olympic

On the other hand, Olympic paints offer a more budget-friendly alternative.

Their prices usually range from $20 to $40 per gallon. While Olympic may not be as high-end as

Benjamin Moore, they offer a wide range of products suitable for various needs and are praised for their good coverage and value for money.

Pro Tip: While considering the price, don’t forget to take into account the number of coats you’ll need and the coverage of the paint. A cheaper paint may require more coats or may not last as long, potentially costing you more in the long run.

It’s essential to consider both your budget and your project’s requirements when choosing between Benjamin Moore and Olympic.

If budget is a concern, Olympic offers a great value product. However, if you’re looking for a premium finish and long-lasting durability, Benjamin Moore might be worth the investment.

In my own experience, I’ve found that spending a bit more on high-quality paint like Benjamin Moore can sometimes save money in the long run.

The superior coverage meant I needed fewer coats, and the durability of the paint meant less frequent touch-ups or repaints.

However, when I was working on smaller projects or areas less exposed to wear and tear, Olympic served me well and kept my costs down.

Ultimately, the choice will depend on your specific needs and budget.

Color Options

When it comes to color options, both Benjamin Moore and Olympic offer a diverse range, allowing you to find the perfect hue for your project.

Benjamin Moore

Benjamin Moore boasts an impressive selection, with over 3,500 colors to choose from.

Whether you’re searching for a cool neutral, a vibrant red, or a soothing blue, Benjamin Moore likely has a color to match your vision.

Known for their rich and true-to-sample colors, they provide customers with a high degree of precision in color matching.

Additionally, their Color Portfolio App and ColorReader device enable you to visualize your chosen colors in different light conditions and on various surfaces, which can be a tremendous help in decision-making.

Olympic

Olympic, although having a slightly less extensive color palette, offers over 1,200 hues.

This range still allows plenty of room for creativity and customization in your paint projects.

Olympic’s colors are noted for their brightness and consistency, with the color appearing on the wall often very close to the sample.

They also offer a digital color picking tool, which allows you to try different shades on virtual rooms before making a decision.

It’s worth noting that both brands offer color matching services.

If you have a specific color in mind not directly available from their range, you can bring a sample to a retailer, and they can mix a custom color for you.

In conclusion, while Benjamin Moore offers a more extensive color range, both brands provide a wide array of options that cater to varied tastes and styles.

Your choice will depend on your specific color needs and the project you’re undertaking.

Availability

The availability of paint products varies between Benjamin Moore and Olympic due to their distinct distribution strategies.

Benjamin Moore

Benjamin Moore takes a specialized approach to its retail distribution, focusing on selling its products through independently owned paint and hardware stores.

This commitment to small business support ensures high-quality customer service and paint knowledge at every location.

They have more than 7,500 locations across North America, making their products relatively accessible, though perhaps not as ubiquitous as some other brands.

Furthermore, you can purchase Benjamin Moore paints online directly from their website, allowing you to conveniently order from home.

Olympic

Olympic, on the other hand, is commonly found in larger home improvement chains, such as Lowe’s.

This wide distribution through popular retailers means that Olympic paints are easily accessible in most areas. Olympic no longer sells their paint products directly online.

Customers can, however, buy Olympic paints online through third-party retailers like Lowe’s, or use the store locator feature on the Olympic website to find the closest physical retailer.

In terms of availability, both brands are broadly accessible but through different channels.

Benjamin Moore focuses on independent stores and online direct sales, whereas Olympic is primarily available in large chain stores and online via third-party retailers.

Your choice between the two will depend on your shopping preference: whether you value the personalized service offered by independent stores or the convenience of shopping at large home improvement chains.

Environmental Impact

The environmental impact of paint products has become an important consideration for many consumers. Here is a look at what both Benjamin Moore and Olympic are doing to reduce their impact.

Benjamin Moore

Benjamin Moore has made significant strides in reducing the environmental impact of their products.

They have a range of low-VOC and zero-VOC paints, which are less harmful to the environment and human health.

In addition, their manufacturing facility in New Jersey has received a Green Seal GS-11 certification, reflecting a commitment to eco-friendly practices in the production of their paints.

Benjamin Moore also participates in sustainability initiatives, such as the U.S. Green Building Council’s LEED program.

Olympic

Olympic also shows a strong commitment to eco-friendly practices.

Notably, they offer a line of low-VOC and zero-VOC paints, including Olympic ONE and Olympic ASSURE, which are marketed as environmentally friendly options.

Moreover, Olympic’s commitment to sustainability is reflected in their receipt of the Master Painters Institute’s (MPI) Green Performance Standard certification for some of their products.

Olympic has also initiated a paint recycling program in select locations, supporting a more circular economy.

Both companies are making concerted efforts to reduce the environmental impact of their products.

This includes offering low-VOC and zero-VOC paint options, obtaining certifications for sustainable practices, and participating in sustainability initiatives.

Your choice between the two may depend on the specific environmental criteria you prioritize and the specific products you are considering.

Personal Experiences 

I recall a client from a few years back who was torn between these two brands for painting their living room.

They loved the cost-effectiveness of Olympic but were also drawn to a specific Benjamin Moore color. After some deliberation, they chose Benjamin Moore and were delighted with the result.

The unique color and exceptional coverage brought a remarkable transformation to their space.

Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs)

Q. Does Benjamin Moore offer better coverage than Olympic?

  A: Coverage can vary significantly based on the specific product line and color chosen.

Both brands offer high-quality paint that generally provides good coverage. 

However, it’s always recommended to do a sample test before painting an entire room or house.

Q. Do both brands offer oil-based paints?

  A: Yes, both Benjamin Moore and Olympic offer oil-based paints. These can be beneficial for certain uses, such as painting trim or furniture, due to their durability and finish.

Q. Are these paints safe to use indoors?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Olympic offer interior paints that are designed to be safe for use in indoor environments.

However, it’s always a good idea to ensure adequate ventilation when painting indoors, regardless of the type of paint used.

Q. How long do these paints take to dry?

  A: Drying times can vary based on factors like the type of paint, the thickness of application, and the environmental conditions.

Generally, most latex paints from both brands will be dry to the touch within an hour and ready for a second coat in 4 hours.

Oil-based paints typically take longer to dry.

Q. Do either of these brands offer chalk paint?

  A: Benjamin Moore offers a line of chalkboard paint, which can create a writable surface on walls or furniture.

Olympic does not have a specific line of chalk paint, but their latex paints can be used with a chalk paint medium for a similar effect.

Q. What kind of primer should I use with these paints?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Olympic offer their own lines of primers, which are designed to work optimally with their paints.

The right primer will depend on your specific project and the surface you’re painting.

Q. Do they have stores, or are they only available in larger home improvement stores?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Olympic paints are available in a variety of locations.

Benjamin Moore paints are sold at independent retailers, including their own branded stores.

Olympic paints are often found in larger home improvement chains, but also online and at various independent retailers.

Q. Do both companies offer color matching services?

  A: Yes, both Benjamin Moore and Olympic offer color matching services.

This can be a great option if you’re trying to match an existing color in your home or find a paint color that matches a specific piece of decor.

Q. Are Benjamin Moore or Olympic paints more resistant to fading?

  A: Both brands offer paints that are designed to be resistant to fading.

The specific level of fade resistance can depend on factors like the color of the paint, the specific product line, and the conditions where the paint is applied.

Q. Which brand offers a wider variety of finishes?

  A: Both Benjamin Moore and Olympic offer a variety of finishes, from flat and matte to eggshell, satin, semi-gloss, and high-gloss.

The best finish for your project will depend on the look you want to achieve and the conditions in the area you’re painting.

Conclusion

In the Benjamin Moore vs. Olympic debate, your decision will likely hinge on your budget, color preference, and desired quality.

If a wide array of colors and top-tier quality is essential and you’re comfortable with a higher price, Benjamin Moore would be your best bet.

Conversely, if you’re on a budget but still desire a decent quality paint, Olympic might be your go-to choice

Suggested Products:

Benjamin Moore

  1. Benjamin Moore Regal Select: This is a high-quality, 100% acrylic latex paint known for its excellent coverage, durability, and washability. It offers a smooth application and comes in a variety of finishes for both interior and exterior uses.
  2. Benjamin Moore Aura: Aura is a premium line of paint that uses proprietary Color Lock technology, offering remarkable durability, extreme hide, and colors that stay true over time. It is also available in a range of finishes.
  3. Benjamin Moore Advance: This is an alkyd-based interior paint that behaves much like an oil paint, but with the ease of a water-based product. It is excellent for high-traffic areas and frequently cleaned surfaces like cabinets, trim, and doors due to its durable and furniture-like finish.

Olympic

  1. Olympic ONE: Olympic ONE is a paint-and-primer-in-one product that offers excellent durability and hide. It is resistant to mildew and stains and can be used for both interior and exterior applications.
  2. Olympic Maximum Stain + Sealant: This product is a popular choice for exterior wood projects as it offers both stain and weather protection, providing durability and water repellency to protect against cracking, splitting, and warping of the wood.
  3. Olympic Rescue It!: This is a resurfacer and sealant product designed to cover worn or weathered wood and concrete, helping restore its look. It’s great for decks, patios, and more, providing a new, slip-resistant surface.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}