Rustoleum vs Krylon: Which Paint Brand Is Best for Your DIY Projects?

Bob Thomas

Introduction

When it comes to DIY projects, choosing the right paint can make a world of difference.

Two of the most popular paint brands available on the market are Rustoleum and Krylon.

Both brands offer a wide range of products, including spray paints, brush-on paints, primers, and more.

But which brand is best for your specific project?

In this article, we'll compare Rustoleum and Krylon, discussing their product offerings, performance, and overall value to help you make an informed decision.

Quick Summary

Rustoleum: is known for its 1) durable, protective coatings, making it 2) ideal for outdoor projects and surfaces that require long-lasting protection. Krylon:, on the other hand, is 3) known for its drying time and wide 4) range of colors, making it a 5) great choice for indoor projects and decorative purposes. Both brands have their strengths and weaknesses, so choosing the right one will depend on the specifics of your project.

Product Offerings

Rustoleum offers a wide range of products, including spray paints, brush-on paints, primers, sealers, and specialty coatings. 

Some of their popular product lines include Stops Rust, Universal, Painter's Touch, and Specialty.

Rustoleum is particularly known for its protective coatings and rust-prevention products, making it a strong choice for outdoor projects and metal surfaces.

Krylon also has an extensive product range, including spray paints, brush-on paints, primers, and specialty products.

Their popular product lines include COLORmaxx, Fusion All-In-One, and Chalky Finish.

Krylon is known for its quick-drying formula and wide selection of colors, making it ideal for indoor projects and decorative purposes.

Performance

Rustoleum is known for its durability and long-lasting protection.

Their products are designed to withstand harsh weather conditions and resist rust and corrosion.

This makes Rustoleum an excellent choice for outdoor projects or surfaces that require additional protection.

However, Rustoleum products may take longer to dry compared to Krylon.

Krylon, on the other hand, is known for its quick-drying formula, which can be a significant advantage for indoor projects or when time is a constraint.

Krylon's products typically dry to the touch within 10-15 minutes, allowing for faster project completion.

However, Krylon's products may not be as durable or long-lasting as Rustoleum's, especially in harsh outdoor environments.

Value

Both Rustoleum and Krylon offer a wide range of products at various price points.

Rustoleum tends to be slightly more expensive due to its focus on durability and protective coatings.

However, the additional cost can be worth it for projects that require long-lasting protection.

Krylon, while typically more affordable than Rustoleum, offers a wide variety of colors and finishes, making it a great choice for decorative projects.

The quick-drying formula can also save time and effort, adding to the overall value of Krylon products.

Pros And Cons

Here's a table comparing the pros and cons of Rustoleum and Krylon:

Attribute
Rustoleum
Krylon

Pros

Durability

Excellent, long-lasting protection

Good, but may not be as long-lasting

Rust Prevention

Superior rust prevention

Adequate rust prevention

Outdoor Use

Ideal for outdoor projects

Suitable for outdoor projects

Indoor Use

Suitable for indoor projects

Ideal for indoor projects

Drying Time

Longer drying time

Quick-drying formula

Color Range

Wide range of colors

Extensive color selection

Product Range

Extensive, including specialty coatings

Extensive, including specialty products

Price

Slightly more expensive

Generally more affordable

Cons

Drying Time

Longer drying time

Not a concern

Durability

Not a concern

May be less durable in harsh conditions

Rust Prevention

Not a concern

Less effective than Rustoleum

Outdoor Use

Not a concern

May not be as long-lasting

Indoor Use

May take longer to complete projects

Not a concern

Price

May be more expensive

Not a concern


Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs)

Q. What types of finishes do Rustoleum and Krylon offer?

  A: Rustoleum offers a wide range of finishes, including gloss, semi-gloss, satin, flat, metallic, hammered, and textured.

Krylon also provides a variety of finishes, such as gloss, semi-gloss, satin, flat, metallic, and glitter.

Q. Are Rustoleum and Krylon suitable for plastic surfaces?

  A: Yes, both brands have products specifically designed for use on plastic surfaces.

Rustoleum's Universal and Painter's Touch 2X Ultra Cover product lines include options for plastic, while Krylon has Fusion All-In-One and ColorMaster Paint + Primer for plastic surfaces.

Q. How quickly do Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints dry?

  A: Rustoleum spray paints typically dry to the touch within 20-30 minutes and are fully dry in 24 hours.

Krylon spray paints generally dry to the touch within 10-15 minutes and are fully dry in 24 hours.

However, drying times can vary based on factors like temperature, humidity, and the specific product being used.

Q. Are Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints UV-resistant?

  A: Yes, both brands offer UV-resistant spray paints. Rustoleum has UV-resistant clear topcoats, while Krylon offers UV-Resistant Clear Acrylic Coating to protect against fading and yellowing caused by UV exposure.

Q. Can Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints be used on fabric?

  A: While not specifically designed for fabric, some Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints can be used on fabric, but they may not be as flexible or long-lasting as fabric-specific paints.

It's recommended to use fabric-specific spray paints or fabric markers for optimal results on fabric.

Q. How well do Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints adhere to metal surfaces?

  A: Both Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints adhere well to metal surfaces.

Rustoleum is particularly known for its rust prevention and durability on metal, while Krylon also provides a strong bond and protection for metal surfaces.

Q. Can Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints be used for automotive applications?

  A: Yes, both Rustoleum and Krylon have product lines designed for automotive applications.

Rustoleum's Automotive and Professional product lines are suitable for various automotive projects, while Krylon offers products like Automotive Primer and Automotive High Heat in their automotive lineup.

Q. Are there any environmental or safety concerns with Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints?

  A: Both Rustoleum and Krylon spray paints are subject to safety and environmental regulations. It's important to follow the manufacturer's instructions for use, storage, and disposal.

Ensure proper ventilation while using spray paints, and wear appropriate safety gear such as masks, gloves, and goggles.

Conclusion

Choosing between Rustoleum and Krylon for your DIY project will depend on your specific needs and preferences.

Rustoleum is the better choice for outdoor projects and surfaces requiring long-lasting protection, while Krylon is ideal for indoor projects and decorative purposes due to its quick-drying formula and extensive color range.

Both brands have their strengths and weaknesses, so consider your project's requirements before making a decision.

Suggested Products:

Rust-Oleum:

  1. Rust-Oleum Universal All Surface Spray Paint: A versatile spray paint that can be used on various surfaces such as wood, metal, plastic, and more. It offers excellent adhesion, coverage, and durability with a smooth, even finish.
  2. Rust-Oleum Painter's Touch 2X Ultra Cover: This fast-drying spray paint provides twice the coverage of competitive brands and is suitable for indoor and outdoor projects. It is available in a wide range of colors and finishes.
  3. Rust-Oleum Stops Rust Protective Enamel: Designed specifically to protect and prevent rust on metal surfaces, this spray paint offers excellent corrosion resistance and long-lasting protection.

Krylon:

  1. Krylon COLORmaxx Spray Paint: With excellent adhesion, coverage, and durability, COLORmaxx is suitable for use on various surfaces such as wood, metal, and plastic. It is available in a wide range of colors and finishes.
  2. Krylon Fusion All-In-One: This spray paint is specifically designed for use on plastic and provides excellent adhesion without the need for primer or sanding. It is also suitable for other surfaces, including wood, metal, and more.
  3. Krylon High Heat Spray Paint: Designed for use on surfaces exposed to high temperatures, this spray paint is perfect for grills, fire pits, and other high-heat items. It provides a durable, protective finish that withstands high temperatures and resists chipping and fading.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}