Sherwin-Williams vs. PPG Pittsburgh Paints: A Detailed Analysis for the DIY Enthusiast

Bob Thomas

Introduction

Hi, Bob Thomas here, bringing you a comprehensive comparison of two popular paint brands.

As a painter and decorator with a lifetime of experience, I’ve painted everything from walls to fences to sheds.

Today, we’re diving into the details of Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints, a topic I've often deliberated over during my many coffee breaks on job sites.

Quick Summary

Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints are both excellent brands that offer a wide range of products. Their strengths lie in different areas – Sherwin-Williams shines for its color variety and durability, while PPG offers great coverage at a more affordable price point. When choosing between them, consider the specific requirements of your painting project.

Overview

Sherwin-Williams, established in 1866, is a renowned global provider of paints and coatings.

They offer a vast range of paints suited for different needs and have a notable presence in paint stores worldwide.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints, on the other hand, is a brand under PPG Industries, one of the largest and oldest paint manufacturers globally.

Known for their innovation and quality, PPG Pittsburgh Paints offer a good selection of paints for homeowners and professionals alike.

Coverage and Durability

In my years of painting, I've noticed that Sherwin-Williams paints generally provide excellent coverage.

For instance, their SuperPaint, a paint and primer in one, often covers in just one or two coats.

Plus, it holds up well over time, resisting fading and chalking.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints are also great in terms of coverage, particularly their Timeless Interior line, which can effectively hide previous colors.

However, some homeowners have reported needing multiple coats for darker colors.

Pro Tip: When painting over a dark color with a lighter hue, use a high-hiding primer to improve the coverage.

Price

When it comes to price, Sherwin-Williams tends to be on the higher end, reflecting its premium position in the market.

However, the cost can be justified by the paint's durability and coverage, requiring fewer coats and less frequent repaints.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints is more moderately priced, making it an attractive option for those on a budget without compromising quality.

Availability

Both brands have wide availability, but Sherwin-Williams has more standalone stores, providing a personalized experience for shoppers.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints are widely available at big-box retailers and independent dealers.

Color Options

Sherwin-Williams takes the cake here. They offer an extensive color palette of more than 1,500 hues, making it a go-to for decorators seeking the perfect shade.

The brand's ColorSnap Visualizer is also a nifty tool for visualizing colors in your space.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints has a solid range of colors, but not quite as many as Sherwin-Williams.

However, their Voice of Color program offers curated color palettes that simplify the color selection process.

Environmental Impact

Both Sherwin-Williams and PPG have made strides in creating eco-friendly paints.

Many of their products have low or zero VOC (Volatile Organic Compounds) levels.

It's worth checking individual product specifications to make the best choice for your health and the environment.

Personal Experiences  

As a veteran painter, I've used both brands on different occasions.

I recall a time when I was working on a heritage property renovation.

The owners were very particular about maintaining the home's historic character, and the vast color options from Sherwin-Williams were a lifesaver.

Conversely, while repainting a local community center on a tight budget, the quality and affordability of PPG Pittsburgh Paints proved invaluable.

Frequently Asked Questions Section (FAQs)

Q. What types of paints do Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints specialize in?

  A: Sherwin-Williams offers a wide variety of paints, including interior, exterior, wood, metal, concrete floor, and industrial paints.

They're also known for their specialized paints like Emerald, Duration, and SuperPaint lines.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints similarly provides a diverse selection.

They offer interior and exterior paints, primers, and specialty products such as their Break-Through line for hard-to-paint surfaces and their Manor Hall line, known for its stain-resistance and durability.

Q. Do Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints offer paint samples for trial?

  A: Yes, both brands do. Sherwin-Williams offers Color to Go samples, which are small, tinted samples of the actual paint.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints provides 8oz samples of any color you choose, allowing you to try the paint in your space before making a larger purchase.

Q. What customer service and support options do Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints provide?

  A: Both brands offer in-store consultation services to help customers make informed decisions.

Sherwin-Williams has more standalone stores, allowing for more personalized service.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints' presence in big-box retailers often includes trained staff members to assist with your paint selection. 

Online, both brands offer tools to help choose colors, simulate them in your space, and calculate the amount of paint needed for your project.

Q. How does the warranty policy of Sherwin-Williams compare to PPG Pittsburgh Paints?

A: Warranty terms differ across products for both brands.

Sherwin-Williams offers a limited lifetime warranty for several of their premium paints, such as the Duration Exterior line. 

PPG Pittsburgh Paints also provides warranties; for instance, their Timeless line comes with a lifetime guarantee.

However, terms and conditions apply for both brands, so it's important to read the warranty details for the specific product you're considering.

Q. Can I order Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints online?

  A: Yes, you can.

Sherwin-Williams has an online shop where you can buy their paints, and they also offer curbside pickup at their stores.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints can be ordered online through various retailers, and in some locations, you can also opt for home delivery or curbside pickup.

Q. What type of surface preparation do Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints recommend?

  A: Both brands emphasize the importance of surface preparation to achieve a smooth and durable finish.

This usually involves cleaning the surface, sanding if necessary, and using a primer.

Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints both have extensive resources on their websites and in stores to guide DIY enthusiasts and professionals in the preparation process.

Q. Are there any paint recycling programs offered by Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints?

  A: Sherwin-Williams runs a paint recycling program at select stores, allowing customers to bring in old, unused paint for proper disposal.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints, being available through various retailers, doesn't offer a direct recycling program, but many paint retailers do have recycling programs, so it's worth checking with the place of purchase.

Conclusion 

At the end of the day, the choice between Sherwin-Williams and PPG Pittsburgh Paints depends on your project's specifics, budget, and personal preferences.

Remember, the best paint for you is the one that fits your project’s needs. 

Suggested Products:

Sherwin-Williams

  1. Emerald Interior Acrylic Latex Paint: This is a high-quality interior paint and primer in one, known for its exceptional coverage, washability, and resistance to staining. It is low VOC and comes in a variety of finishes, including matte, satin, and semi-gloss.
  2. Duration Exterior Acrylic Coating: Duration is Sherwin-Williams' premium exterior paint line. It's designed to be a one-coat cover for most surfaces, is highly resistant to peeling and blistering, and it's available in a wide range of colors and finishes. This paint is known for its durability and weather resistance.
  3. SuperPaint Interior Acrylic Latex: SuperPaint offers excellent performance at a more mid-range price. It also features paint and primer in one and is known for its good coverage, durability, and easy application. It's suitable for a wide range of interior surfaces.

PPG Pittsburgh Paints

  1. PPG Timeless Exterior Paint and Primer: This line is known for its exceptional durability and protection against harsh weather conditions. It's a paint and primer in one, providing excellent coverage and resistance to fading.
  2. PPG Manor Hall Interior Paint, Primer & Stain Repellent in One: Manor Hall paints are popular due to their stain-repelling properties and durability. The line offers excellent coverage, a smooth finish, and is resistant to mildew.
  3. PPG Break-Through! Interior/Exterior Paint: This is a high-performing, versatile paint that can be used on a wide variety of surfaces, including hard-to-paint materials. It dries quickly, is highly durable, and provides excellent adhesion and hardness, making it a favorite for both interior and exterior use.

About the author 

Bob Thomas

A fully certified interior decorator and house painter , Bob Thomas brings immense expertise and knowledge amassed from many years of hands-on experience with residential, commercial and specialty painting and decorating projects of all sizes and scopes.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}